Tips for offering constructive criticism

At some point, you'll come across an image that simply does not resonate with you. You might even feel offended by a photographer's particular artistic choices in lighting, color grading, posing, or even subject matter but, I implore you, if you're a going to leave feedback — make it constructive.

A few things to consider before leaving feedback

  • Did the artist ask for feedback?
  • Am I the intended audience for this work?
  • Do I understand the meaning behind the work?
  • Is my feedback actionable or based a personal preference?

Here are a few tips for providing actionable and meaningful feedback:

  • Start Positive: Highlight what works well in the photo.
  • Be Specific: Focus on details like composition, lighting, or focus.
  • Ask Questions: Encourage reflection and dialogue.
  • Offer Solutions: Suggest ways to improve, not just what to change.
  • Use a Supportive Tone: Be respectful and encouraging.
  • End Positively: Reinforce the photographer’s strengths and potential.

We should be good stewards of art by lifting up artists in our community. I hope these tips empower you to share your thoughts in a way that's actionable and helpful for the recipient.

Have a great day, friends.