What's a game that has aged both extremely well, and extremely poorly?

I was playing Tony Hawk's Underground 2 yesterday, and parts of it are as good as they ever were. The skating is still buttery smooth, and the soundtrack might be the best collection of licensed songs in the series. And then there's the story, which heavily features Jackass-style antics and Bam Margera. I didn't like Bam Margera back when he was still cool, and he's now a 50 year old man still acting like a teenage idiot.