mascara help??

im hoping this gets some traction because i have a really specific problem with my mascara, i'm super picky about my eyelashes. i have long eyelashes, but i've noticed that more recently, they've been thinner and fall out more frequently, which kind of happened out of the blue. i used lash sensational for a while and loved it because it separated my eyelashes really well, but it just wasn't giving me that wow factor. i switched to maybellines firework mascara and the first 2-3 uses were perfect, but now i've noticed so much more fallout on my right eyelashes. the mascara is still so wet and the formula is so thin that my eyelashes just clump together and fall and i'm literally losing my mind (if you couldn't already tell lol). i need drugstore mascara recommendations, preferably something that's like maybellines lash sensational but slightly more dramatic. i've tried loreals telescopic and found it to be quite wet as well, so far i've been eyeing maybellines falsies lash lift mascara, and l'oréal panorama, but i want opinions and thoughts.

what are some good mascara recommendations for people with longer lashes who prefer a dramatic, volumized, and separated look? also what do you guys use to keep your eyelashes strong/healthy/growing? i use the lash serum from elf right now but i'm open to try anything else. i've heard castor oil is good as well.

the first photo here is me wearing lash sensational, the second photo is the first time i tried maybellines firework (loved it), and the third photo is what it looks like now every time i try to use the firework mascara (after separating/fixing my eyelashes). as you can see, my right eye is the difficult eye, i have the most fallout and thinner lashes on that side.