Was George Hodel really the Black Dahlia killer? What’s your take?

For those unfamiliar, George Hodel was a physician whose own son, Steve Hodel (former LAPD detective), has spent decades building a case against his father.

Evidence pointing to Hodel:

• His surgical skills could explain the precise nature of Elizabeth Short’s wounds
• He owned the Sowden House during the time of the murder (which some believe could have been the crime scene)
• Alleged police surveillance recordings where he supposedly made incriminating statements
• His son’s investigation connecting him to other murders in the “Black Dahlia Avenger” books
• Photo evidence that may show Hodel with Elizabeth Short before her death
• He fled to Asia shortly after becoming a suspect

Counter-arguments: • No physical evidence directly tying him to the crime • Some critics believe Steve Hodel’s investigation is biased due to his relation • The case has attracted many “solutions” over the years • LAPD never officially named him as the killer

I’m curious what others think - is Steve Hodel’s case against his father convincing? Are there other suspects you find more compelling? What pieces of evidence do you find most convincing or problematic?

This case has haunted Los Angeles for over 75 years, and I’d love to hear this community’s insights.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/26/black-dahlia-murder-steve-hodel-elizabeth-short