What's something in a fan made roster that grinds your gears?
Personally I hate how damn repetitive so many fan rosters are now, I kid you not show me 10 fan rosters and they all have either crash, waluigi, geno, sans, alear from fire emblem engage or meowscarada, where tf is the originality, geno is stuck in legal hell and there's not much to base his moveset around, alear and meowscarada will 100% definetly get picked over characters from the most recent games and the whole waluigi thing was funny at first but now it's getting annoying I'm not sorry
and with all the veterans it's always "daisy should have a moveset based on the sports games" THAT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE daisy was first introduced in super Mario land on the game boy, a mainline Mario title, she can have a couple moves from the sports games sure I would love that but not base her entire moveset around it, she didn't even originate from a sports game so why base her moveset around it?
Also some of the cuts, especially with rosters that try to be "realistic" are bias and bias alone, some rosters will have more star fox characters than fire emblem characters, all the pokemon are kept from gen 1 maybe with an exception for either greninja or lucario, a lot of them have some dumb rule that goes like "none of the OG 12 are getting cut" when that's not even a probability and no 3rd parties are cut, when 3rd party licensing is annoying as hell, I'm sorry but a lot of cuts will unfortunately be made if there is a smash 6
OK I've got all of that out of my system, let me know what you guys think and what you like/don't like about fan made rosters