What if Brad Rutter or Ben Chan competed against Yogesh Raut & James Holzhauer at Jeopardy! Masters Episode 1 Game 2 instead of actual Producers Pick Amy Schneider?

Disclaimer: This is for discussion purposes. To the tabloid writers: please don't use my thread as gainful use of clickbait & sensational journalism. My discussion post was approved by the moderator group.

Since majority of the people think that Michael, Lisa, Sarah, Bari, Sony & ABC made the wrong decision of selecting Amy Schneider (which it was a unanimous vote) as Producers Pick at Jeopardy! Masters Season 2 over Brad Rutter (which some people claimed that he doesn't need to qualify at Jeopardy! Invitational Tournament because he won UTOC, BOTD & ASG prior to his huge loss at GOAT) or Ben Chan (2024 TOC-1st Runner Up), what if either Brad or Ben C competed against Yogesh Raut & James Holzhauer during the first episode of the show, would you think they can beat Yogesh and/or James or the results be the same because Yogesh won the actual game via runaway?

Do you Amy's 3rd place in her first game this season & currently in last place in the overall standings proved that other players should had been her place at JM2?