What baggu should I get for everyday?

Edit: what’s everyone’s thoughts on the duck bag?

I normally use a tote bag but want something sturdier.

What is normally in my bag is : 24oz owala, hardcover or paperback book, A5 journal, pen, phone, portable charger, lipgloss, deck of cards, Bluetooth over ear headphones, umbrella sometimes.

I want a bag that can hold all of this comfortably but not look stupid if there’s less in it, have a comfortable enough strap, and possibly have room for extra things if I go shopping. I am 5’3” for reference for size.